Monthly Deposits vs a Higher Rate: Which Moves the Result More?
Four scenarios
Monthly compounding, deposits at month end, no fees.
| Scenario | You contribute | Balance |
|---|---|---|
| $300 at 5% | $72,000 | $123,310 |
| $300 at 7% | $72,000 | $156,278 |
| $400 at 5% | $96,000 | $164,413 |
| $400 at 7% | $96,000 | $208,371 |
The catch
You control deposits; you do not control the rate. A higher rate usually means more risk, and a promised rate that is too good deserves caution. A deposit increase is certain, a rate increase is not.
Over longer horizons
| Years | $300 at 5% | $300 at 7% | $400 at 5% |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | $46,585 | $51,925 | $62,113 |
| 20 | $123,310 | $156,278 | $164,413 |
| 30 | $249,678 | $365,991 | $332,903 |
| 40 | $457,806 | $787,444 | $610,408 |
The rate's advantage widens with time because it compounds; the deposit's advantage grows only in proportion.
Common mistakes and how to avoid them
Before chasing a higher rate, check what extra risk or cost it carries. A fund charging 1% more in fees cancels most of a 1-point gain in return, as the SEC bulletin explains. For savings accounts, compare APY rather than the quoted rate and check whether the rate is promotional. Deposit increases can be automated and raised each year: a 3% yearly raise on $300 at 5% for 20 years gives $157,800 against $123,310 flat. Combining modest improvements in both, like the $400 at 7% row, gives $208,371, but only the deposit part is within your control. If you can only change one thing, change the one you can guarantee. To verify any figure on this page yourself, use the formula FV = P(1+r/n)^(nt) for a lump sum, where P is the starting amount, r the annual rate as a decimal, n the compounding periods per year and t the years. For regular deposits add the term PMT x ((1+r/n)^(nt) - 1) / (r/n). Every table here was produced by code that implements exactly these formulas and is the same code the calculator uses, so entering the stated inputs should reproduce the numbers to the dollar. If your own result differs, the usual causes are a different compounding frequency, deposits made at the start rather than the end of each month, or a rate entered as a whole number where a decimal was expected. Rounding in the middle of a calculation can also move the last digits, so keep full precision until the end and round only the figure you report.
Use the calculator
Test your own numbers.
Sources
Related
Educational estimate, not financial advice. Found an error? Tell us.