Start vs end of month deposits: does timing change compound growth?
The numbers: $300 a month at 7%
| Period | Deposit at month end | Deposit at month start | Extra from depositing early |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 years | $51,925.44 | $52,228.34 | $302.90 |
| 20 years | $156,278.00 | $157,189.62 | $911.62 |
| 30 years | $365,991.30 | $368,126.25 | $2,134.95 |
Depositing at the start of each month always ends exactly 0.583% higher with monthly compounding at 7%, because every deposit gets one extra month of growth. In dollars that is $302.90 after 10 years and $2,134.95 after 30. Useful, but it will not change your plan.
Why the gap is a fixed percentage
With end-of-month deposits D, the deposits grow to D × [(1+i)N − 1] / i. Moving every deposit one month earlier multiplies the whole stream by (1 + i), where i is the monthly rate. In Excel this is the type argument of FV(): 0 for end of period, 1 for start.
=FV(7%/12, 360, -300, 0, 0) vs =FV(7%/12, 360, -300, 0, 1)
What this means in practice
- Match the calculator to reality. If your paycheck deposit lands mid-month, the truth sits between the two columns.
- Investing a lump sum. If you already have a year's contributions in cash, investing it at the start of the year keeps it invested longer: if prices rise over the year it ends higher, and if they fall first, spreading it out would have done better. Choosing between them is a risk preference, not a math question.
- When comparing calculators, check timing first. It explains many small discrepancies.
Frequently asked questions
Which timing does Investor.gov use?
Investor.gov's calculator adds the monthly contribution to the principal every month; our calculator lets you choose start or end so you can match any tool.
Does deposit timing matter for a savings account?
Very little: at 4% to 5% one month of extra interest on each deposit is a fraction of a percent of the balance.
Is it better to invest yearly in January or monthly?
If the money is available in January, investing it then gives it more time in the market. Monthly investing suits money that arrives monthly from a paycheck.
Sources
Related
Educational estimate, not financial advice. Found an error? Tell us.