How to compare bank deposit growth with APY
Compare on APY, not on the headline rate
Banks must disclose the annual percentage yield (APY), which includes compounding, on deposit accounts. Three hypothetical accounts, each with $10,000 and no further deposits:
| Account | Stated rate | Compounding | APY (computed) | After 1 year | After 5 years |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Account A | 4.00% | monthly | 4.074% | $10,407.42 | $12,209.97 |
| Account B | 4.05% | yearly | 4.050% | $10,405.00 | $12,195.80 |
| Account C | 3.90% | daily | 3.977% | $10,397.68 | $12,152.98 |
Account B quotes the highest nominal rate, but it compounds once a year; Account A's monthly compounding gives it an APY of 4.074% against B's 4.050%. The comparison is only meaningful when you convert to APY, or when the bank has already shown it. Details in APY vs APR. Rates here are made up for the example; they are not current offers.
A monthly fee can erase the difference
Take a 4% APY account (yearly steps for simplicity) and subtract a monthly maintenance fee, as some accounts charge unless you meet a minimum balance:
| Monthly fee | Balance after 5 years | Cost of the fee vs no fee |
|---|---|---|
| $0.00 a month | $12,166.53 | $0.00 |
| $5.00 a month | $11,841.55 | $324.98 |
| $10.00 a month | $11,516.57 | $649.96 |
| $15.00 a month | $11,191.59 | $974.94 |
Fees are subtracted from the balance so they stop earning interest too. Our guide on how fees change compound growth shows the same effect with percentage fees.
Adding regular deposits
Starting with $10,000 and adding $200 a month at 4% for 5 years yields about $25,470: $22,000 contributed plus $3,470 interest. If your rate is variable (most savings accounts), run the calculator at a lower rate too. Real returns after inflation are lower again (see inflation-adjusted growth).
Checklist before you choose
- Compare APY, and check whether it is a promotional rate with an end date.
- Check minimum balance, monthly fees, and withdrawal limits.
- Confirm the bank is FDIC-insured (or the credit union NCUA-insured). Standard FDIC coverage is up to $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, per ownership category.
- Interest is generally taxable income; your bank reports it to tax authorities.
Sources
Related
Educational estimate, not financial advice. Found an error? Tell us.